User talk:BoyGoyle

Re:Kaworu's page
It's undue weight. You don't need to go into huge detail of all the options you can have in videogames, particularly when there are dozens of those involving multiple other characters. They'd go into the games' and manga actual pages, and they are sufficiently detailed there along with the others. For the same reason that I can't say that Shikinami "might" have been based off Moyoco, for instance, we can't just say Anno and Sadamoto "seem to believe" something, when the same sources already listed don't say that, or the overall context doesn't lead into it - you put into context what Sadamoto says about the nature Rei's feelings, Kaworu's curiosity about humanity, not understanding these feelings, why Shinji rejects him and consider other sources (manga commentary, Cut interview, parano etc), etc. Supplemental material in general rarely if ever say anything that is not exceedingly obvious - Chronicle for instance is some 15 pages combined saying something like "Kaworu approached him and Shinji was surprised", and the usually recycle text from the program books and film books. They make a deliberate point to not say anything you can't figure out on your own. It's nothing compared to what you get from Asuka or Rei, though their articles don't get all that much detail either, and shouldn't, because it's largely meaningless and could be used to reinforce one argument, breaching NPOV. I don't see the reasoning behind some of the interjections made either, like assuming there is some meaning behind him only having a half route in GoS 2 when it's simply because the developers had to rush to finish the game and Rei and Asuka are more of a priority. The other articles also (generally!) mention extra-canonical appearances as multiple options, so that needs to be standardized. Some of the other affirmations are inaccurate, like the CI being sanctioned proper by Gainax... but that isn't necessarily the problem, as you are mistaking a third party game guide for some of the alternative scenarios in NGE2, and that info is absent from the actual Classified Information. The scenarios go into all sorts of fanservice, and don't even pretend to be canon, according to Gainax and the game devs themselves - see the Neon Genesis Evangelions article for more information. In that same game, Kaworu can be seduced Ritsuko. Yes, really. So I think you can see why the guide to one out of 18 scenarios is not worth a lot of consideration about the character proper. FelipeFritschF (talk) 18:21, 21 February 2021 (UTC)

Re: Justice for Kaworu
your edits were such a vast improvement and it's a shame they were reverted...also you were spot on with how people are cherry-picking things and downplaying canon... stay strong king