User blog comment:Master Plaga/What makes SEELE think they have the right to choose our fate?/@comment-1589281-20130527143946

There are three ways to answer your question IMO

1) They are anime characters, they are the "bad guys" and want everyone to be perfect forcing their ideals. So, long story short, Anno didn't think about them being right or wrong, they want this to happen, they do not care about everyone's opinion, they think they're right. Therefore they could be actually considered "villains" and it is useless to look to deep into their motivations.

2) Humans don't have right to stop the angels in the first place. They should be the actual real earth inhabitants. Anywasy if they had the proof of what they're saying is right, then...yes they should have actually that right. In NGE universe human are not just a mass of cells, they actually have a "soul" that creates a body using AT field and LCL. Where these souls go after death isn't explained, but if they actually become new people or just dissolve, it has more sense to unificate them all to become the "perfect being". But what's exactly this perfect being? A new angel? Just a bunch of souls inside a giant ball? (black moon) No question given. So no, they don't have that right, it's just their ideal unless they have the roof of what they're saying.

3)Eva is filled with what I think are plot holes (Gendo perfect plans that don't make any sense for example). Not because we aren't given any informations, but because these informations aren't even known by the characters. It's still unclear what these "dead sea scrolls" actually are. It is still unclear what really happened in second impact and how angele generated. Yet out of nowhere these guys have a plan to bring humanity to "perfection"? How? With what knowledge?